Footsteps on the Mountain blog

Connect
Follow me on TwitterLike me on FacebookFollow me on TumblrSubscribe to my RSS feeds
Watch my YouTube channelFollow me on Google+See my Amazon profileSee my Goodreads profile

Footsteps on the Mountain

May 14, 2014 4:06 pm, by Mark Horrell<< Return to blog home

A last desperate bid for Everest glory … by helicopter

It’s been a terribly unhappy 2014 Everest season for many reasons, so here’s something to cheer us all up. We all thought the season on the south side of the mountain finished two weeks ago after officials from the Ministry of Tourism flew into Base Camp by helicopter to eat omelette and pancakes before flying out again (I’m not kidding, I watched this happen). But various reports in the Himalayan Times over the last few days have fuelled speculation that the Southeast Ridge may yet be climbed this year.

A helicopter flies over Everest Base Camp, but have climbers been chartering them to fly into the Western Cwm?

A helicopter flies over Everest Base Camp, but have climbers been chartering them to fly into the Western Cwm?

On Friday they reported that two legendary female mountaineers Cleo Weidlich and Jing Wang still intended to climb the mountain by chartering a helicopter to fly them up to Camp 2 in the Western Cwm (“legendary” isn’t the adjective most people would use to describe these women). Neither climber was being supported by their original teams: Weidlich was planning to climb the mountain solo, while Jing had hired 7 new Sherpas to help her. The report contained a number of inaccuracies, not least by stating Weidlich had already flown to Camp 2 when in reality she was still at Base Camp, and that various expedition operators had hired helicopters to transport her equipment up there for her (these operators had indeed hired helicopters, but only to cache the equipment their Sherpas had originally carried up there in preparation for next year).

Then on Sunday they stated Jing had also flown up to Camp 2, and this report was given more credence when Russell Brice, owner of her original outfitter Himex confirmed it in a newsletter, stating that he did not support her attempt. Both women are relatively inexperienced climbers with no real idea of what they are facing. Without the help of their teams the chances of success are virtually nil.

But what if a fully supported team were to return to Everest and try again by flying into the Western Cwm by helicopter, where they would find tents, stoves, food and ropes which had been cached there from earlier in the season? Would such a team have any chance of success? The Everest season was shut down for a number of reasons, chief among them because the Khumbu Icefall was considered too dangerous this year, Sherpas who did climb faced physical threats and intimidation from other Sherpas who did not want them to, and the Icefall Doctors who maintain the route through the Khumbu Icefall were no longer working. By flying into the Western Cwm, the Khumbu Icefall would be bypassed and some of these reasons would no longer be applicable.

As I sat in New Orleans bar in Kathmandu drinking Belgian beer with my two remaining team mates from the Altitude Junkies team, Margaret and Edita, we read about the madcap scheme of these two “legendary female mountaineers” and hatched one of our own. Most of our Sherpa team were still in Lukla awaiting a flight back to Kathmandu. Did any of them fancy another tilt at the mountain? Supposing we could persuade our expedition leader Phil Crampton to charter a helicopter for us and mobilise the Junkies into action again, perhaps we could still climb? The three of us were on Lhotse permits rather than Everest, so not as much rope would be required to fix the route. Margaret pulled out her phone and we began texting him.

You may find this exchange more entertaining if you consider the context. It’s been an exhausting and stressful season for Phil, but at last it’s nearly over. Our equipment had only just arrived from Lukla and he was on his hands and knees cleaning out the tents at his office in Thamel when the phone rang …

Phil Crampton explains by text message why climbing Everest is not practical this year

You will see from the last message in the sequence that we decided to leave New Orleans, buy some beers in a supermarket and take them round to Phil’s office. But when we arrived we found it locked up; the place was deserted and Phil had made his escape. With him went any last remaining chance of a commando raid on Lhotse’s summit by the Junkies. We can assume from this that, chopper or no chopper, according to Phil Crampton there will be no summits from Everest’s south side this year.

That’s as maybe. On the positive side, rarely have I had so much fun sitting in a bar waiting for someone’s phone to go beep.

You might also like:

Tags: | | | | | | | | | | | |

| << Return to blog home

Please help me raise money for education in Nepal ...

sponsor me for CHANCEIn my spare time I am a trustee of CHANCE, a UK charity who strive to give young people in Nepal better opportunities in life by providing teacher training, and inspiring them to take part in the Duke of Edinburgh's International Award.

If you enjoy this blog it would be fantastic if you can give me a big thumbs up by making a donation. You can also help by getting sponsored for an event or travelling to Nepal with their partner trekking agency. Here are the other ways you can help.

If you prefer not to then that's OK too. I enjoy going on expeditions and writing the blog, and will continue to do both of them anyway.

Comments (11)

  1. Robert Kay said:

    Don’t forget the Minister also enjoyed some garlic soup so the trip was more productive than you give him credit for!

  2. Mark Horrell said:

    Good heavens, I’d forgotten about the garlic soup. If only there were a means of transferring that to the Minister’s Swiss bank account. ;-)

  3. Mel Huang said:

    Hi Mark,drink more beers with Phil, if you decide to resume the climbing, let me know, I will fly to Kathmandu from Shanghai tomorrow.

  4. Mark Horrell said:

    Heehee, good to hear from you, Mel. I knew you would join us, but remember to bring your head lamp! ;-)

  5. Raheel Adnan said:

    Mark,
    Maurizio Folini says, “Weidlich flew on May 8 from Gorak Shep(5,164 meters)”, which is in agreement with HT report (on May 9th).

    http://www.montagna.tv/cms/60281/everest-sud-due-alpiniste-rimangono-a-provare-le-cime-e-salgono-a-campo-2-in-elicottero

  6. Mark Horrell said:

    Hi Raheel,

    Thanks for sending the link. Very interesting, though not 100% convincing. It contradicts the statements we were receiving from Sherpas in base camp, who said Cleo was still there, so somebody’s wrong.

    The report is in Italian, so some of the facts might be getting lost in translation, but here’s a summary of what I think’s being said here.

    The Italian helicopter pilot Maurizio Folini, who works for Fishtail Air, says he transported Cleo Weidlich from Gorak Shep to Camp 2 in the Western Cwm on May 8, and Jing Wang a couple of days later.

    Folini also says he transported all of their equipment, including 2 miles of rope, and that it took 12 flights to accomplish this. I wonder how many of these flights involved carrying just the rope? This was one of the issues that was highlighted by Phil when we were grilling him about the practicalities of another attempt: there’s simply not enough rope in the Cwm to fix the route to both summits (Everest and Lhotse). Two miles of rope (3200m) is barely enough to fix the route up Lhotse (whose summit is 2100 vertical metres about Camp 2), and is nowhere near enough to go all the way up the Southeast Ridge to the summit of Everest.

    What Folini hasn’t said is how much he charged for the flights. Earlier reports suggest $2,000 USD per flight, which means a grand total of $24,000, small change for Ms Jing, who owns a clothing company and wealth numbered in millions, but an astronomical sum for most of us (and probably Cleo Weidlich).

    The plot thickens. The only thing I know for sure is the chances of a south side summit this year haven’t improved much!

    Regards,
    Mark.

  7. Raheel Adnan said:

    Hi Mark,
    Thanks for detailed analysis.

    Indeed, the chances of success on Lhotse and Everest this season are still minimum (or almost non-existent if we consider acclimatization of two climbers and weather forecast). Even North side teams aren’t expecting summit attempts before May 27th.

    However, Ms Jing’s situation reminds me of a 2013 news story (probably incorrect), that a Chinese millionaire hired a full team to fix separate ropes for him on Everest North side.

  8. Brian said:

    Just stumbled upon this site as I was reading up on Jing Wang. Contrary do your description of her (which seemed a little disparaging), Jing Wang doesn’t seem to be “inexperienced” before her Everest summit this year:

    Previously, she had summited Everest twice, Lhotse, Nuptse, Manaslu, Broad Peak and Lobuche Peak. On the Himex website, it states “…she climbed the steep technical slopes of Nuptse and then 4 days later climbed Everest a feat that few can do. I am also quite amazed at how this lady can achieve so many mountaineering feats…” (on the Himex website).

    She herself states “…I had a lot of experience climbing 26,000-foot (8,000 meter) peaks nine times.” (National Geographic article about her)

    In 2014 alone before her Everest climb, she reached the South Pole (Jan 15), Mt Vinson (Jan 22), Aconcagua (Jan 31), Elbrus (March 14), and North Pole (sometime in April), and some other peaks.

    My point is that your article gives the impression that she’s inexperienced and reckless (though not many words were said), which I think was a quick and unjust judgement on your part.

  9. Mark Horrell said:

    My issue with Ms Jing as not so much her climbing CV as the manner she uses her wealth to pursue her agenda with little consideration for the consequences it has for other people.

    Can you tell me how much she paid her 5 Sherpas to take her up Everest when others were on strike or fearing repercussions if they worked? Can you tell me how her wages compared with those of other Sherpas, or how her own Sherpas’ community reacted when they returned home with unspeakable wealth?

    Can you tell me how much she paid to government officials to present her with an engraved plaque in an elaborate ceremony to mark her achievement (http://www.thehimalayantimes.com/fullNews.php?headline=Wang+to+receive+mountaineering+award+today&NewsID=419764) while they were banning the pilot who flew her up Everest from operating (http://thehimalayantimes.com/rssReference.php?headline=Italian+pilot+pays+price+for+airlifting+Wang&NewsID=420042).

    It’s likely her actions will have other consequences. While she was busy flying up Everest in pursuit of her Seven Summits record her expedition leader Russell Brice of Himex was making representations to the Nepal Ministry of Tourism on behalf of Sherpas and clients. These included better working conditions for Sherpas and an extension of the permit fee for clients who had been unable to climb because of the strike. Instead of listening to his pleas, which would have benefited all parties in the future, the Ministry turned a blind eye and threatened him with a ban from operating because of the actions of his rogue client Ms Jing. It is possible they may use her ascent as a reason for not extending the permit fee, by claiming it proves people could climb Everest despite the strike.

    I don’t know whose respect she is trying to earn by pursuing her Seven Summits record so ruthlessly. Perhaps it is businesses in China who she hopes will provide her with sponsorship if she succeeds. Perhaps it is consumers in China who she hopes will buy more products from her outdoor equipment company.

    But if she’s hoping for respect from the mountaineering community then your list of her summit successes means little when weighed against the means she has used to attain them and the effect it will have on the community. Who knows, perhaps she flew up some of the others too, leaving a trail of destruction in her wake …

    When she has finished bagging her Seven Summits record with whatever means she has at her disposal (for what that’s worth) I hope she will think about the consequences of her actions and use her wealth more positively and considerately in future.

  10. Pingback: Looking back on Everest as the dust settles – Footsteps on the Mountain

    […] Every word I’ve read about her climb until now has been negative, including my own slightly tongue-in-cheek post […]

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Lively discussion is welcome, but if you think your comment might offend please read the commenting guidelines before posting.

Enter your email address

Latest comments

  1. “[…] When is a summit not a summit? […] ”

  2. “Incredible footage! That settles it. I'm staying in Arizona. Looking down those ice ridges would give this desert dweller …”

  3. “[…] Last week I posted a trip report of our ascent of 6440m Cholatse in Nepal’s Khumbu region. The report …”

Archive

The Ascent of Manaslu by Mark Horrell, available as an ebook here